Skip to main content

" The RSS : A Menace to India" Review

 

The RSS was established as an armed , militant wing of Hindu Nationalism in order to overpower and wipe out Indian Nationalism from the country: Noorani





    In April 2019 India was in the first phase of 2019 general election and 'fir ek baar , Modi sarkar ' slogan was sweeping across the country. Just one month before the election, a book was launched by LeftWord Books in the India International Centre ( New Delhi) . Not much attention was paid to the book by the 'liberals' of this country and no book discussions were held by the 'mainstream' media houses. The Hindu Nationalist Narendra Modi (as he called himself) came to power again . The book is titled " The RSS : A Menace to India". 

    Starting with the quote by Dr.Ambedkar "If Hindu Raj does become a fact , it will ,no doubt , be the greatest calamity for this country...Hindu Raj must be prevented at any cost' the book ' The RSS  : A Menace to India' written by the most notable Supreme Court lawyer , a constitutional expert and a author A . G . Noorani opens up a full spectrum of the largest organisation of the country- The RSS ( Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh). The voluminous book contains 25 chapters with more than 500 pages and 16 appendices. 

The book is a historical report of communalism  in pre-independence to post independent India dwelling till the present Modi era. From Hedgewar to Golwalkar, Mookherjee to Advani , every bigshot of the Hindutva ideology finds a place in this book. 

    The book deals with the peculiar relationship between the RSS ,BJP and its progeny , the ABVP , VHP and the Bajrang Dal. The author makes his way by dwelling into the first revolt of united India against the colonial rulers i.e the revolt of1857 when the Hindus and the Muslims stood together in the lost battle. But on the parallel a majoritarian ideology was making its way to enter into the Indian politics. 

    The author doesn't forget to mention in the first chapter itself an address given by RSS chief Bhagwat's on 27 October 2017 where Bhagwat said " Hindustan is a country of Hindus. It does not mean that Hindustan is not the country of other people ". Bhagwat didn't mention whom he was referring to as the "other" people. This has been the crux of the fascist ideology anywhere in the world i.e "We" and the " others". The RSS and BJP don't believe in the "minority" theory . The ideological difference between Indian nationalism and the Hindu nationalism is well explained by Mr. Noorani. But the author didn't visit the 'caste ' issue in relation to RSS in detail.

The author left no stone unturned by providing a reference to his each and every remark about RSS. The authors view that too with factual references of  collaboration of RSS  and the Hindu Mahasabha with the colonial rulers us makes question the very existence of the RSS and its allies . The RSS ideology of "Hindu Nationalism" is based on the similar lines of Musslini's "Italian Fascism" and it's outreach is ever increasing after the Ayodhya incident.  The Hindu reported in 2019 that the RSS is growing at an annual rate of 20-25% with 50000 daily shakhas, 5-6 lakhs people attend them. 

    The book also covers the period when the differences between the BJP and RSS were out in the open and how RSS rose to the level of  controller of BJP while reminding it it's ideological foundation. The Advani episode booked a separate chapter revolving around his relations with the RSS and its allies along with the leaders of BJP including PM Modi. Advani ignored the happenings around him which ultimately resulted into his sidelining from the mainstream leadership and the parallel rise of Modi as an alternative and also the topmost choice of the RSS. The 2002 Gujarat riots and the response of Narendra Modi as a CM is also being critically noted by Noorani by citing the testimonies of two of the country's top police officials and media correspondents .  Narendra Modi is being chosen by RSS to lead the country. After 2014 a fear of the atmosphere has been evading the homes of minorities and there are reasons for that as the author cites a report of Indian Express ( 20th April 2018) which said " any move in favor of minorities looks illegitimate in the era of majoritarianism ". The  people have reasons to believe in the fear instilled by the daily propaganda.  Be it journalists , be it common citizens , everyone is being targeted if they criticize those in power. New terms like "anti-national, urban-naxals, tukde tukde gang" are being invented everyday to degrade and silence the dissent. 

    The author warns the readers that the 'poison is spreading alarmingly......What is at stake is not only the Indian Dream. What is at stake is the soul of India.' 

    If you are a voracious reader and take interest in Indian political history , partition of India and the rise of communalism in India, this book is a concise option for you. 





The book is available on the following link: 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

IS GANDHI FAMILY A BLESSING OR BURDEN FOR THE CONGRESS ?

     Going through the history from 1985 to 1970 Congress was a cadre based party valuing its workers and leaders. But the situation changed rapidly after the 1969 split when Indira Gandhi was ousted from the Congress Party by S. Nijalingappa. Then Congress (I) became a dominant party , emerged victorious thereafter and Indira Gandhi leadership turned into a “personality cult” in the span between Bangladesh Liberation war and emergency. The Congress turned deeply towards dynastic politics when Rajiv Gandhi was made PM. Old Guards Vs Young Turks :      If we will look towards Congress Party history we get that whenever there is a leadership crisis in the Congress, the party looks towards the Gandhi family and this is what happened in the 2019 CWC meeting when Sonia Gandhi was made interim president . Weren’t there other leaders from the Congress other than the Gandhis to lead the party? Yes there were leaders like Bhupesh Baghel (now Chhattisgarh CM), Captain Amarinder Singh, Shashi Tha

India’s Security Post 26/11

                         India’s Security Post 26/11 26 November 2008,it was a cool evening ,everything seemed calm everywhere except the running of passengers to catch the local train-the lifeline of Mumbai. No one was expecting that after sometime all is going to change. A disaster came for which we were caught unprepared partially if not completely. TV sets were tuned into news channels as they started streaming the live coverage of terror attacks on multiple locations in Mumbai-the heart of Indian Economy. A cool-calm evening was turned into heart wrenching nightmare. It took 3 days for the attack to come to an end only when  NSG (NATIONAL SECURITY GAURDS)  in co-operation with the local security apparatus ended the siege by eliminating all the militants except one (Kasab) .The attackers did what they wanted to. That is to terrorize the civilian population, foreign tourists( probably jews) ,foreign investors ,etc. Ajmal kasab's interrogation and the surveillance sy

D For Democracy ,Not Dictatorship

Going by the book, Democracy is the system of governing for the people, by the people and of the people. Apart from this, what people know about democracy is that the elected representatives engage into the governing system to satisfy common man’s demand and  to make a harmonized society . But what will happen when the elected representatives no more represents the people’s will ? What if the people are not allowed to raise their demands? What if the the people who asks questions to the system are called as anti-national? What if the elections are rigged? What if the basic constitutional tenets are harmed by the elected representatives?  Then comes the real question of DEMOCRACY which we have taken for granted and of the constitution drafted by Dr.Ambedkar. The democracy in the minds of our constitution makers meant – a committed judiciary, press committed to profession and not to political parties, concerned and awake citizens who preserve all liberties that go to make a democrati